401(k) Rollover Decision Guide
Compare old employer 401(k), IRA rollover, and new employer plan options using fees, investment choices, taxes, and convenience.
Prompt Template
You are a retirement planning educator. Help compare 401(k) rollover options for: Country/account type: [e.g., US 401(k), similar employer pension account] Old employer plan balance: [amount] Old plan fees and investment options: [expense ratios, admin fees, funds available] New employer plan options: [if available] IRA options being considered: [brokerage, fees, investment menu] Account type: [traditional/pre-tax, Roth, mixed, after-tax] Need for backdoor Roth IRA: [yes/no/unsure] Loan, creditor protection, or rule-of-55 considerations: [if relevant] Desired investing style: [simple index funds, managed, ESG, self-directed] Decision priorities: [lowest fees, simplicity, investment choice, tax flexibility] Create: 1. Side-by-side comparison table 2. Key tax and operational questions to verify 3. Pros/cons of leaving funds, rolling to IRA, or rolling to new plan 4. Fee impact example over time 5. Red flags and paperwork checklist 6. Recommendation framework, not a one-size-fits-all answer State that this is educational and the user should verify details with the plan administrator or a qualified advisor.
Example Output
401(k) Rollover Decision Framework
| Option | Pros | Cons | Best Fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leave old 401(k) | No immediate paperwork; institutional funds | Limited support; possible admin fees | Strong low-fee old plan |
| Roll to new 401(k) | One workplace account; may preserve backdoor Roth flexibility | New plan may have weaker fund menu | Simplicity + good new plan |
| Roll to IRA | More investment choice; easier consolidation | Can complicate backdoor Roth due to pro-rata rules | No backdoor Roth need + low-cost IRA |
Questions to Verify
- Are there account maintenance fees in the old plan?
- Does the new plan accept incoming rollovers?
- Are any balances Roth or after-tax?
- Will an IRA rollover affect future backdoor Roth contributions?
Fee Example
On a $75,000 balance, moving from 0.65% all-in fees to 0.08% saves about $427/year before compounding. Over 20 years, that difference can become meaningful.
**Paperwork checklist:** direct rollover form, receiving account details, check payable instructions, beneficiary update, confirmation of pre-tax/Roth treatment.
Tips for Best Results
- 💡Ask the AI to flag backdoor Roth and pro-rata rule issues before recommending an IRA rollover.
- 💡Use actual fund expense ratios when possible; fee differences sound small until modeled over decades.
- 💡Prefer direct rollovers over indirect rollovers unless the user understands the deadlines and withholding rules.
Related Prompts
Personal Budget Builder
Build a realistic monthly budget based on your income, expenses, and financial goals using the 50/30/20 or zero-based method.
Debt Payoff Strategy Planner
Create a step-by-step debt payoff plan using the avalanche or snowball method with a timeline and total interest saved.
Investment Basics Explainer
Get a plain-English explanation of investing concepts tailored to your knowledge level and financial situation.